Radical Honesty Isn’t a Policy. It’s a Habit.

And it starts with the small stuff you think doesn’t matter

A few months ago, my family flew to a remote island in Indonesia to start a sailing trip. Our boat captain was supposed to meet us at the airport. When we emerged from baggage claim, squinting in the tropical heat, nobody was there.

He showed up nearly 30 minutes later, full of excuses. He didn’t know we’d be traveling without checked bags. There was a dignitary in town and traffic had been a disaster. Elaborate stuff, all of it easily disproven.

He was lying to us. About something that didn’t matter at all.

We weren’t going to miss the boat. There was no real hurry. If he’d just said, “Sorry — I was getting the boat ready and lost track of time,” we would have forgotten about it before we reached the dock.

But instead of nothing, he gave us something we didn’t ask for: a reason not to trust him. If he’d lie so easily about something this small, what would he do when there was an inconvenient truth we actually needed to know?

———

I’ve worked with a compulsive liar. A genuine one — someone who could say things that were completely untrue with total conviction, about things that were easily disproven and offered no obvious benefit.

He told stories about his wedding. (He’d never been married.) He mentioned classes he’d taken and degrees he’d earned. (Neither.) And in his finest moment, he mentioned he’d been in the tunnel in Paris the night Princess Diana was killed.

I don’t know how he kept it all straight. And I know at some point it got expensive. He once offered me his fourth-row Lakers season tickets if I was ever in LA. A few weeks later, I called his bluff. He produced the tickets — which I found out later he’d gone out and bought. Another time he offered the use of his cabin on Lake Tahoe, which happened to be “undergoing renovations” just days before I was supposed to arrive, so he’d arranged for me to use a friend’s place instead. Rented. For the weekend.

All of this to maintain fictions that cost more to keep up than they’d ever been worth.

———

Honesty was never something I decided should be part of the Netflix culture. It’s just how I’ve always operated. And it’s what drew Reed Hastings and me together — we started carpooling before we started a company, and somewhere in those early morning commutes, we figured out that we could just… say what we thought. That turned out to matter a lot.

It’s what let Reed and me argue like cats and dogs about almost every aspect of Netflix without it ever getting personal. We were both just trying to build the best company we could. And when I was struggling as a leader, it’s what allowed Reed to tell me so — without me wondering if there was something else going on. I didn’t have to guess what he really thought. I already knew.

That kind of culture doesn’t get announced. People see it and they either match it or they don’t.

———

Think about how many companies announce someone’s departure by saying they’re “leaving to spend more time with family” or “pursuing other opportunities.” Everyone in that room knows it’s not true. You’ve just stood up in front of your team and lied to them. And somewhere in the back of their heads, they’ve filed that away.

Next time they see a problem, they’ll think twice before saying so.

———

On a weeklong sailing trip, a captain who lies about small things costs you a low-grade unease. On a years-long entrepreneurial journey, it costs you the ability to actually see what’s happening — which is just about everything.

There’s no safe place to draw the line between acceptable dishonesty and unacceptable. You can’t quarantine the small stuff. The small stuff is exactly where the pattern gets set.

My boat captain thought he was smoothing things over. What he was actually doing was teaching me, quietly, not to trust him.

Here’s the thing about trust: you can lose it in thirty seconds. Getting it back takes forever — if it comes back at all.